top of page
  • Writer's pictureSarah Turney

Ayla Reynolds

Today I am discussing the case of missing 20-month-old Ayla Reynolds. According to Ayla’s father Justin DiPietro, on December 16, 2011, he put her to bed at 8pm and when he woke up she was gone. Justin and his family are convinced that Ayla was abducted. However, law enforcement quickly dispelled this theory and accused Justin and those in the house the night Ayla went missing of knowing more than they are sharing with investigators. Despite some pretty damning evidence, years of fighting and lawsuits, and this quite literally this becoming the largest search for a missing person in the history of the state of Maine, Ayla’s case remains unresolved.

Listen Now:

Poster for sharing:

How to help:

If you have any information about Ayla please call the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit at 207-624-7143.

District Attorney Megan Maloney -623-1156 or


December 18, 2011, Conference-

October 23, 2013, Conference-


13, CBS. “Judge Gives Mother of Ayla REYNOLDS More Time to Find Girl's Father.” Bangor Daily News, 19 Mar. 2019,

13, CBS. “Missing Toddler's Blood Was from When She Was SICK, Attorney FOR Ayla Reynolds' Father Says.” Bangor Daily News, 17 May 2019,

Adams, Glenn. “Maine Police: Missing Toddler Is Likely Dead.” The Burlington Free Press, 1 June 2012, p. 6B.

Adams, Glenn. “No Evidence of Abduction of Tot, Police Say.” The Boston Globe, 31 Jan. 2012, p. B2.

Associated Press. “Missing Maine Toddler Declared Dead.” The Burlington Free Press, 28 Sept. 2017, p. 11A.

Associated Press. “Year Later, Maine's Ayla Reynolds Case Is Mystery.” The Rock Island Argus, 16 Dec. 2012, p. A13.

“Ayla Bell Reynolds.” The Charley Project,

“Ayla Reynolds 911 Transcript (Part 1).” Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel,

“Ayla Reynolds 911 Transcript (Part 2).” Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel,

Barber, Alex. “Fearful That Investigation Will Go Cold, Mother of Missing Toddler Ayla REYNOLDS Set to Make Evidence Public.” Bangor Daily News, 30 May 2017,

Barber, Alex. “Tips on Ayla Pour in after Reward Offer.” The Bangor Daily News, 28 Dec. 2011, p. B1.

Bard, Chelsea. “Eight-Year Anniversary of Ayla REYNOLD'S DISAPPEARANCE.”, 17 Dec. 2019,

Campbell, Cindy. “Ayla Reynolds' Mother Says Father Has Disappeared.” Q106.5, 14 Mar. 2019,

Contributed. “Investigators Call out Adults Who Were Home with Toddler Ayla Reynolds.” Bangor Daily News, 30 May 2017,

Contributed. “Police: Blood Found At Ayla Reynolds' Father's Home.” Bangor Daily News, 30 May 2017,

Cousins, Christopher. “Police Confirm Blood Found IN Toddler's Father's Home Is Ayla's.” Bangor Daily News, 30 May 2017,

Cousins, Christopher. “Timeline of THE Ayla Reynolds Case.” Bangor Daily News, 30 May 2017,

Crimesider. “New Details Emerge in Ayla Reynolds Case as Father, Grandmother Speak Out.” CBS News, CBS Interactive, 9 Jan. 2012,

Crimesider. “Report: Ayla Reynolds' Father Took out Life Insurance on Toddler before She Disappeared.” CBS News, CBS Interactive, 15 Feb. 2012,

Curry, Colleen. “Ayla Reynolds' Mom Unable to Complete Polygraph.” ABC News, ABC News Network,

“Department Narrative.” District Attorney's Office, Kennebec County, Maine,

Gagnon, Dawn. “Ayla Reynolds 911 Call Transcript Released.” Bangor Daily News, 3 Feb. 2014,

Gluckman, Neil. “Demonstrators at Waterville Police Department Demand Arrests in Ayla Reynolds Disappearance Case.” Bangor Daily News, 25 Jan. 2014,

“Justice for AYLA Reynolds, Organized by Jeff Hanson.”,

Koenig, Seth. “Father of Ayla Reynolds Responds to Wrongful Death Lawsuit.” Bangor Daily News, 15 May 2019,

“Missing Girl's Grandmother Changes Story.” CNN, Cable News Network, 10 Jan. 2012,

“Missing: What Happened to Baby Ayla Reynolds? - Pt. 1 - Crime Watch Daily.” YouTube, Crime Watch Daily, 23 May 2016,

“Missing: What Happened to Baby Ayla Reynolds? - Pt. 2 - Crime Watch Daily.” YouTube, Crime Watch Daily, 23 May 2016,

“Missing: What Happened to Baby Ayla Reynolds? - Pt. 3 - Crime Watch Daily.” YouTube, Crime Watch Daily, 23 May 2016,

NBC10 Boston. “Ayla Reynolds' Mother: Time Is Running out to Find Father in Wrongful Death Lawsuit.” NBC Boston, NBC10 Boston, 13 Mar. 2019,

Sharp, David. “Foul Play Suspected in Girl's Disappearance.” The Brownsville Herald, 1 Jan. 2012, p. A7.

Sharp, David. “Missing Maine Toddler Generates Online Discussions.” Rutland Daily Herald, 2 Apr. 2012, p. A2.

Sharp, David. “Mother Wonders If She'll See Ayla Again.” Bangor Daily News, 21 Dec. 2011, pp. A1–A2.

Smith, Craig, and Hearst Television Inc. “Photos: Timeline of Ayla Reynolds Investigation.” WMTW, WMTW, 4 Oct. 2017,

Today Show. “Dad of Missing Child: 'I'll Do Anything to Get My Daughter Home'.”,

“Spiral Fractures: Mcbride ORTHOPEDIC HOSPITAL.” Spiral Fractures | McBride Orthopedic Hospital,

“Transcripts Detail Justin DiPietro's 911 Call Reporting Ayla Reynolds Missing.” Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel, 14 Dec. 2016,

WGME. “Tuesday Marks 8 Years Since Ayla Reynolds Disappeared.” WGME, WGME, 17 Dec. 2019,

Whittle, Patrick. “20-Month-Old Ayla Reynolds Disappeared 7 Years AGO. Now Her Mother Is Suing Her Father.”, The Boston Globe, 17 Dec. 2018,

WMTWTV. “Ayla Reynolds News Conference.” Facebook, 17 Dec. 2018,

WMTWTV. “Ayla Reynolds 911 Transcripts Released.” YouTube, YouTube, 3 Feb. 2014,

WMTWTV. “Ayla Reynolds News Conference.” YouTube, YouTube, 31 May 2012,

WMTWTV. “Maine State Police Update Search FOR Ayla Reynolds.” YouTube, YouTube, 23 Oct. 2013,

WMTWTV. “Uncut: Police Discuss Missing Toddler Case.” YouTube, YouTube, 18 Dec. 2011,


Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page